top of page

Characters in Rutherford's life

Niels Bohr.jpg

Niels Bohr (1885-1962)

    Ernest Rutherford and Niels Bohr met in late 1911 and began working together in 1912.

    While Rutherford was a born experimenter (despite a slight tendency to clumsiness), Bohr soon abandoned laboratory work to concentrate on theory. It would appear that he was even more clumsy than his mentor.

    Nevertheless, their collaboration was most fruitful, since it gave birth to a model of the atom that is still taught today (even if it does not fully explain the world of the infinitely small).

    However, in the case of Bohr, the bonds that were forged from the spring of 1912 had another meaning: the young Niels, who had lost his father the year before, found in Ernest an older man to serve as a reference (even though they were only 14 years apart).

    Moreover, when Niels Bohr got married in the summer of 1912, he left Rutherford's laboratory in Manchester only very briefly: after having married Margrethe on August 1, Niels was already back in England on the 12th: he was eager to introduce his young wife to the one who would become his surrogate father.


    The two images opposite show Margrethe and Niels during their engagement, in 1910, and during their golden wedding, in 1962.
Niels Bohr died on November 18, 1962, three months after the second photo.

18108621016178375.jpg

       But let's go back to the days of their youth.

       

    Upon his return from Manchester in 1912, Niels became a lecturer at thePolytekniske Læreanstalt (Polytechnical Educational Institution) in Copenhagen, as assistant to Martin Knudsen. But the situation does not suit him at all: he mainly teaches medical students, he has neither the time, nor the equipment, nor the staff to pursue his research.

 

      In March 1914, he therefore requested the creation of a position as professor of theoretical physics at the University of Copenhagen.Rutherford then wrote him a rave letter of recommendation... totally justified, in view of the atomic theory that Niels Bohr developed in 1913.  

  Two months later, however, Rutherford wrote to Bohr again to inform him that Charles Galton Darwin would soon be vacating the lectureship he had held for two years in the physics department at the University of Manchester.  

 

     "Preliminary inquiries show that not many men of promise are available. I should like to get a young fellow with some originality in him."

 

      Rutherford does not wish to invite Bohr too directly to take this position: he knows that the Danish researcher's project is to obtain the creation of a tailormade professorship in Copenhagen. But Bohr understands the implication very easily; and he knows that the developments he hopes for in his native country are unlikely to come about quickly. 

He therefore quits his job and leaves for two years to Manchester.

       Margrethe and Niels first settled in Didsbury, to the south of the city (and more precisely in Victoria Avenue, according to Margrethe's memories collected in 1963 and transcribed on the website of the American Institute of Physics). 

     Niels is a lecturer, but also has time to carry out experiments and work on his own theories. He is also one of the few to push forward the physics department at that time, due to the fact that many young researchers are engaged in the world conflict and Rutherford himself is very busy with his activities within theBoard of Invention and Research.

    During the summer of 1916, the couple returned to Denmark: Niels had just been appointed the chair of the theoretical physics department which had just been created at the University of Copenhagen. It was in this city that their first child, Christian, was born on November 25, 1916. Five other boys followed: Hans (April 7, 1918), Erik (June 23, 1920), Aage Niels (June 19, 1922), Ernest (March 7, 1924) and Harald (1928). 

      Two tragedies will darken the family's happiness: the eldest, Christian, will lose his life at 17 during a nautical trip and the youngest, Harald, suffering from several disabilities, will only live 10 years, carried away by meningitis while he had been placed in an institution since the age of 4.     

        The other four will have very honorable careers, as doctor (Hans), engineer (Erik), lawyer and high-level athlete (Ernest). Aage followed in his father's footsteps, even by receiving, like him, a Nobel Prize in physics in 1975.         Last detail: the penultimate was named Ernest in homage to the New Zealand physicist who guided Niels Bohr during his first steps in the world of atomic physics.

Aage Bohr and Niels Bohr on the occasion of the defence of Aage’s doctoral thesis 1954.PNG

Aage Bohr and Niels Bohr on the occasion of the defence of Aage’s doctoral thesis, 1954

Source : The Nobel Prize

       But before all these events, tragic or happy, Niels had a career to build. So let's go back to 1917.

        As with the teaching position in theoretical physics, Niels decided to move heaven and earth to obtain the creation of an institute devoted entirely to this scientific field. Begun in 1917, his campaign to obtain the necessary authorizations and funding was successful in 1918: the university then gave its agreement and friends of Bohr managed to raise sufficient funds. All that remains is to find land; the city of Copenhagen will provide it. 

        In the fall of 1918, Niels Bohr wrote an enthusiastic letter to Ernest Rutherford announcing his project and asking him if he would agree to chair the inauguration of the new institute. He is optimistic about opening a year later. But this announcement intersects with a letter from Rutherford, in which the latter offers his Danish friend a position as professor of mathematical physics at the University of Manchester. 

        Niels panics: the future that seemed clear to him in Copenhagen is perhaps not the only way to advance his research. What should he do? To respect the confidentiality requested by Rutherford, he does not tell anyone: with Margrethe, he goes to his brother, Harald, and spends the night discussing the pros and cons of each option.

     A few days later, on December 15, he sends his reply to Rutherford:

    « I don't know how to thank you for your letter of November 17, which I have just received and which besides being the source of the greatest pleasure to me has at the same time been the object of sorrowful consideration.

     « You know that it has always been my ardent wish to be able to work in your neighborhood and to take a part in the enthusiasm and imagination which you impart to all your surroundings and of which I have so much benefitted myself. At the same time I am not in a position to accept the splendid offer, and for which I feel more thankful than I can express because of the undeserved confidence in me that it contains.

    « The fact is that I feel I have morally pledged myself to do what I can to help in the development of the scientific physical research here in Denmark, and in which the small laboratory will play a part.

     « I should like so much to settle down in Manchester again and I know it would be of the greatest importance to my scientific work, but I feel I cannot accept the post you write about because the university has done all that they could to place all external means necessary for my work. Of course the pecuniary means, personal allowance as well as that to the running of the laboratory, will be far below the English standard.

     « I feel it is my duty here to do my best, though I feel very strongly the result will never be the same as if I could work with you. »

 

        Back from his Christmas vacations, Rutherford writes to Bohr : 

       "I hope you will not prejudge the question before you have a chance of coming to England to talk things over. I hope you will do so as soon as it is convenient to travel. There are many things in general I want to talk to you about."

      Due to the requisitions of ships and trains to repatriate demobilized soldiers, this trip to England was postponed until the following July. The "things in general" that Rutherford wanted to discuss with Bohr concerned his appointment to Cambridge, his latest results, which seemed to show that he had succeeded in disintegrating atoms and, of course, the proposal he had made to Bohr to work together (whether in Cambridge rather than Manchester changed nothing).

       Bohr congratulated his friend on his new position, he became passionate about his experiments with the decay of nitrogen or oxygen atoms by bombardment by alpha particles... and he confirmed his refusal to come and settle in England.

         It was therefore in Copenhagen that Niels Bohr continued his career, in an institute of theoretical physics whose design and construction he supervised with great rigor. Delays and an increase in the cost of construction led him to request additional funding from the Carlsberg Foundation (which he obtained) and to postpone the inauguration until September 18, 1920. That said, this date was chosen because it suited Ernest Rutherford, but the building was not yet fully completed. It would not be until January 18, 1921, becoming one of the world's leading places for the study of quantum physics.

It would not be until January 18, 1921, the day on which that Bohr, without any delay, moved his papers and books into his new domain. That same day, he wrote his first letter sent from that address—a letter addressed, of course, to Ernest Rutherford.

 

         The official inauguration, attended by the university rector and the Minister of Education, would, however, take place on March 3 of that same year. The Københavns Universitets Institut for Teoretisk Fysik would then become one of the world’s leading centers for the study of quantum physics.

Institut de physique théorique de l'Université de Copenhague - 1921.jpg

Institute of Theoretical Physics at the University of Copenhagen - 1921

Source : Niels Bohr Institute

Bohr & Rutherford, 1933
bottom of page