Characters in Rutherford's life
Otto Hahn (1879-1968)
German chemist Otto Hahn had a clear career path ahead of him, in industrial chemsitry. But when recruiting him, the Chemische Fabrik Kalle & Co made it a condition that he acquire a better level in English, to facilitate the expansion of the company abroad. He therefore left for London, in the laboratory of William Ramsay, discoverer of rare gases (helium, neon, krypton, xenon ... as this chemical family was known at that time) and who was to receive the Nobel Prize in chemistry a few weeks after Hahn joined his team, at the end of 1904.
But Hahn did not only improve his language skills : without ever having handled any radioactive material before landing on the banks of the Thames, he quickly succeeded in mastering the radium purification technique developed by Marie Curie. .
Such a rare talent interested Ernest Rutherford, who brought him to Montreal at the start of the academic year in October 1905 (despite his reluctance to hire a young man trained by Ramsay, whose coup with rare gases had only been followed by absurd ideas... which he tried each time to pass for the invention of the century).
Hahn loved this Quebec experience alongside Rutherford, so much so that Chemische Fabrik Kalle never saw him take the position ha had been planned to take.
The positive point for the young chemist was that he developed over the following decades a whole section of science which was later referred to as "nuclear chemistry" (although we must not forget the role played by Bertram Boltwood and Frederick Soddy in this area, nor the invaluable help that the physicist Lise Meitner gave him, once he was installed in Berlin). His investment finally earned him the 1944 Nobel Prize in chemistry for the discovery of nuclear fission; discovery largely attributable to Lise Meitner... who was not invited to share this honor.
During the rise of Nazism and the war, Hahn remained in Germany without adhering to the Nazi theses (unlike Philipp von Lenard, promoter of Deutsche Physik, a movement which opposed the ideas of Einstein and other representatives of "Jewish science"). He also refused to participate in the work on the atomic bomb wanted by Hitler (unlike Hans Geiger ) and, furthermore, he dare to help his Jewish colleagues (unlike, again, Geiger, who did not lift a finger for its own employees).
According to Albert Einstein, Otto Hahn was “one of the few to remain upstanding and to do their best during those dreadful years."
Pictures:
Otto Hahn in 1910. Source: PRISTEM Università Bocconi, Milano
Otto Hahn and Lise Meitner in 1910. Source: NDR.de
"Bonzenfreie Kolloquium" (conference without the "bigwigs"), conference organized by Lise Meitner for Niels Bohr in Berlin, in 1920. Source: AIP
Munster meeting, Germany, 1932. Source: National Library of New Zealand, Sir Ernest Marsden Papers
Otto Hahn and Lise Meitner in 1962. Source: NDR.de
Pour revenir au séjour d'Otto Hahn au Canada, il faut aussi souligner le point négatif qui en découla : ce fut le choc qu'il ressentit en retournant à Berlin et en retrouvant l'atmosphère compassée et hiérarchisée des universités prussiennes. S'il n'avait pas connu l'ambiance chaleureuse, stimulante, égalitaire et néanmoins respectueuse instaurée par Rutherford au sein du Macdonald Physics Buiding de Montréal, il n'aurait pas souffert de ce violent contraste.
Comme il fallait sans douter, Hahn et Rutherford restèrent amis toute leur vie.
"Bonzenfreie Kolloquium" Berlin, 1920 .
Left to right: Otto Stern, Wilhelm Lenz, James Franck, Rudolph Ladenburg, Paul Knipping, Niels Bohr , Ernst Wagner, Otto von Baeyer, Otto Hahn, George de Hevesy, Lise Meitner , Wilhelm Westphal, Hans Geiger , Gustav Hertz, Peter Pringsheim .
Credit: Prof. Wilhelm Westfall, courtesy AIP Emilio Segrè Visual Archives
Munster, Allemagne, in 1932.
Assis (de gauche à droite) : James Chadwick, Hans Geiger, Sir Ernest Rutherford, Stefan Meyer, Karl Przibram.
Debout (de gauche à droite) : George von Hevesy, Madame Geiger, Lise Meitner, Otto Hahn.
Sources:
Introduction: From Rutherford to Hahn , William R. Shea
The Politics of Memory - Otto Hahn and the Third Reich , Ruth Lewin Sime
Max-Planck-Gesellschaft, Harnack House, History: Otto Hahn (quote from Einstein at the end of the page)
The Path to nuclear fission: the story of Lise Meitner and Otto Hahn , film directed by Rosemarie Reed, written by Michelle Zackheim with guidance from Ruth Lewin Sime, Films for Thought